December 5, 2006
Friendswood: America's new melting pot?
The English vs. Every Other Language debate got a little more heated last night in Friendswood as local officials and residents debated the merits of making English the city's official language. You may remember when the issue came up last week after resident William Hilburn complained to the city that he couldn't communicate with city employees trimming trees near his house.
"He come out and come up and stood right there and was trying to tell me about this 'boothis' and pointing at the tree."[ ... ]
For 10 minutes, the two exchanged hand signals. "He just kept on talking and pointing at the tree and saying "boothis,'" Hilburn said.
After a while, Hilburn arrived at the only logical conclusion: The city employees couldn't speak English, so they must have been illegal immigrants. So he got off his boothis and went to the Friendswood City Council, which first considered adopting a requirement that anyone hired for a city job be able to speak English fluently but later switched to the "official language" amendment to Friendswood's city charter.
Last night, about 80 Friendswoodites Friendswooders Friendswoodonians residents showed up at the council meeting to hear more about the proposal, which Councilman Chris Peden said is not meant to prevent anyone from speaking a non-English language — it's just a safeguard for the future. "Friendswood does not have a language problem in the city now," he said. "I want to head this off before we do." KTRK reports that four councilmembers support the proposal and two don't; one of those two is Laura Ewing, who said the amendment would open the door to future problems. "This has the potential for serious ramifications," she said. "There would be people that take this to extremes. Where do you draw the line?" (Charles Reeves, one resident the Chronicle quoted, apparently plans to draw the line right at the city limit: "You're free to leave if you want to speak another language," he said last night.)
Those in favor of the English amendment say it would simply require all city business to be conducted in English first, which LULAC District 8 Director Rick Dovalina said could be achieved with a resolution rather than a law. Frank Ortiz, a Friendswood resident and former national vice president of LULAC, went a step farther, saying the amendment would lead to discrimination and could bring a suit from LULAC if it's passed. "We have discussed legal action," he said. "We're prepared. The question is, is Friendswood prepared?"




Peden linked non-English speaking to illegal immigration, too - and threw in sex offenders, as well (via the Chronicle):
...the proposed measure would be a safeguard for Friendswood and compared it to the city's ordinance prohibiting sex offenders from living within 2,000 feet of places where children gather.
"We do not have, in my opinion, an illegal immigration issue in the city of Friendswood, but I don't want to pass legislation after we get one," Peden said.
Laura Ewing and current LULAC president Rick Dovalina express how they believe pushing this proposal will have a bad effect on the city - guess what guys, it already has!
but yeah, Reeves' thoughtful comment was my absolute favorite:
"You're free to leave if you want to speak another language," said Reeves, 38, a mortgage broker who has lived in Friendswood for four years.
wtf?!
Something like this would not stop others from speaking whatever language they wish..but when conducting business as a local,city or state government English should be required. It's funny how people bristle at requiring those involved with the public speak English...I wonder what they would say if it were ruled that Police need not speak English?? Or when you go to City Hall nobody spoke English?? Or when the EMT's show up all they can speak is Spanish or whatever?? It appears it's legal to require English for these jobs,so why not others where the public is involved.
i would assume it is because english always has been and currently is the standard - it is the de facto language...
obviously a few are feeling threatened about the future of that.